Today’s newsletter shares a story from my manuscript, a story about what happened to me, as a young child, in our modern culture…
This was a typical Saturday afternoon. Typical Saturday afternoons meant my mother, my younger sister and I could be found wandering the halls of our town’s one and only large shopping mall. The mall was called Carrefour de L’Estrie, which literally translated means Crossroads of the Eastern Townships, but to my family and I, it was more accurately translated as That Big Giant Shopping Mall — The One You Can’t Miss — Smack Dab in the Middle of Our Town.
My father was with us that day, but, as so often happened, he had wandered off on this own, more than likely taking himself to Classics, the small bookstore near the center of the mall, a center decorated by a large, colorful water wheel and the wishing well that lay just beneath it.
Suddenly, seemingly out of nowhere, Danny, a classmate from my second grade class, appeared. I never saw him coming. It was as if a magician had supernaturally conjured him up right there in front of me. Poof… And here he was.
Now, at this time, things were not going well at school, not going well at all, as you might recall from my earlier description of my second grade year. When I’d arrived at my new school, enduring the horrors of my bus trips there, I didn’t know the schoolyard games. Truth be told, even if I had known them, and even when I did eventually learn them, I didn’t seem to have much of the natural talent my classmates possessed. So, most of the time, I sat on the sideline, not invited to join in. During those times, I tried to stay out of sight, hoping to avoid the kids who, had they found me, would have found me to be easy prey. On those rare occasions when I was invited to join in on a game of dodgeball, I, like Charlie Brown in the daily comic strips, was the last person picked.
But, on this particular day, maybe because it was a Saturday, maybe because there weren’t any other school kids around, maybe because we were both freed from the playground and its unspoken rules about who could be seen with whom, Danny seemed unexpectedly excited to see me. He greeted me with a warm smile — it felt like a warm embrace — and with a big “hello”, the kind that said, without having to say it, “of course we’re the best of friends”.
My mood took a sudden turn. It veered from anxious trepidation and headed toward anticipatory excitement.
Then, Danny did something that surprised me even more. He said, and I believe this to be a direct quote, “There’s this great place in the mall. It’s where all the kids go to play. Do you want to go with me? It’s very close to where we are.”
What?
A place in the mall where all the kids go to play?
How in the world had I missed this secret, magical place?
It didn’t matter now. I’d been invited in. I’d been invited to join in by my new best friend.
I could feel the joy welling up from deep inside me. It was the joy of finally, finally, believing, really, truly believing, I’d be welcomed and included.
I was certain I was about to be warmly received by our mall’s secret society of children, a community of loving, open-hearted kids just like the ones in the village of Dani.
I imagined a large room filled with children who’d been been gathering there for weeks, maybe months, gathering each and every Saturday, playing board games and ball games, jumping together in ball pits, running and chasing after one another, screaming with delight and excitement.
I looked up at my mom with big eyes, eyes showing the sort of longing only a child can conjure up, eyes lit up by the promise of hope. My mother looked down at me, smiled, happy to see my happiness, and with this, her non-verbal acknowledgement, I ran off with my friend Danny.
You can more than likely guess what happened next. There was no secret, hidden room in our mall, no room where a secret society of kids came together the way kids did in the village of Dani. There was no Saturday miracle to rescue me from my loneliness.
There was, instead, only an arcade, a tiny arcade tucked between a small pharmacy and an even smaller, non descript corner store. Inside, lining its walls, sat six, or maybe it was eight, colorful pinball machines.
Danny ran over to one of them. He put his quarter in the coin slot. He pulled back then released the plunger, and shot the shiny steel ball up the ramp. Then, he lost himself in a world of bumpers and targets.
Danny glanced over at me. He looked past the dismay and disbelief painting my face. He told me to go find my own pinball machine to play.
“Maybe this is what childhood really is all about,” I wondered. “Standing side by side but never together: next to Danny but apart from Danny; in the classroom but apart from my classmates; at home but apart from my family.”
[This story is part of a larger chapter in my manuscript, a chapter speaking to the separation we can’t help but experience in our modern consumer culture.]
Feeling particularly despondent on a cold winter's night I googled "how modern culture leads to hopelessness" and found your excellent article: "How Modern Culture Drowns Out Psychology’s Important Message - Humans crave connection, but society tells us to prize self-sufficiency." Your writing really hit home for me! You described what I've been feeling for years and have been trying to articulate. I'm not a very good consumer it turns out. I realized long ago that I valued free time more than stuff. So compared to most people in my upwardly mobile area, I am far, far behind. I do not own a house as a single woman in my 60's, I drive an economy car, I am not a crack interior decorator, I have an old cell phone, I don't spend a lot of time on planes, I don't blow money in restaurants. I'm OK with my life as I am aware that my standard of living exceeds most people of the world...however, my more "successful" peers seem entitled to express dismay with my lifestyle and they like to let me know it.
I get hassled a fair amount of not meeting the standards of today's individualist consumer ideals. The fact that I'm a renter is the number one faux pas. Being a renter is treated in this culture like a moral failing, shameful, something to be mocked. I wouldn't dare make rude comments about someone's weight but that overweight person who owns two houses feels quite entitled to make comments about my renter status. I don't want to spend my time creating a living space that looks like it came out of Architectural Digest. I didn't realize I was supposed to be a crack real estate whiz, to know when "the bottom of the market" was and that is exactly WHEN I should buy property so I can then brag about how much it has increased in value.
Thus I am constantly dealing with simmering anger over this ridiculous culture, feeling the condescension and judgement from other consumers around me. It has affected my mental health and probably my blood pressure. On a daily basis I try to calm myself down, deep breathe, smile at dogs and tell myself "No, this is not why you are here - to compete, consume, buy stuff, and display it - BY MYSELF - to be accepted." Yet, this is the current reality. In order to keep up with the proverbial Joneses, I'd have to quit pretty much everything to concentrate on keeping up, competing, buy that condo already (in the 3rd most expensive city in the country) and "stop throwing your money away on rent", then buy those tasteful furnishings, paint the walls the "right" stylish colors, get the most tasteful wall art, work hard to get everything to look "just so" and then have those people over to admire my possessions and decor so that I can approved of, to finally be an esteemed member of their club. That's what is important. Even though we have all heard the old adage, "it's what's inside that counts"...No, not true. Not here, not now. Well, yeah, that's nice but it's what is OUTSIDE that will get social acceptance. What is YOUR property worth? How much do YOU make? What kind of car do YOU drive? Where did YOU take YOUR last vacation? What are YOUR financial goals? What is YOUR retirement plan? What do YOU do? Sigh. No wonder so many are lonely and despondent.
Thank you for your amazingly wonderful warm and keenly observant writing nailing this modern social tragedy. And I will NEVER fit in until I - individually, as a near senior citizen with a partial disability - achieve these consumer ideals BY MYSELF so I can be accepted. Some may say, "Oh, you're exaggerating, it's not as bad as you make it out to be, people are not that materialistic or judgmental"...."You need different friends". Luckily I do have a couple friends who don't care about my decor but they are few and far between. This is why I prefer the company of strangers. They know nothing about my car, my education, my portfolio, my decorating skills or my achievements as an INDIVIDUAL. I'd rather exchange light small talk or cheerful banter with a stranger in a bar than be faced with the judgment of my peers.
Your writing gives me hope and I will come back to these articles to buoy my spirits. I WAS NOT PUT HERE TO BUY STUFF. I AM NOT HERE TO ACHIEVE "SUCCESS" by MYSELF. I AM NOT MY ACHIEVEMENTS. I AM NOT MY THINGS!!!